Casa Amarilla

AMAZING!

Overdue review here.  We visited Key West April, 2024.  I can't say enough about our stay in Key West @ Last Key Realty's rental Casa Amarilla.

 

The rental - A MAZ ING!  it is exactly how it appears on-line and convenient to everything.  The 5 of us (all adults) found it very relaxing and comfortable.  Christian (our host) was onsite to meet us when the house was ready and the Key Lime Pie he left was delicious.

 

Christian and Charlie (our concierge) at Last Key Realty were fantastic.  They were there to help navigate all the small details so that we could enjoy our stay in Key West.  They checked in daily and were very responsive to our questions.

 

Needless to say we are already planning on visiting Key West again next year and will not hesitate to rent with Last Key Realty.

- Mary Anne G , Posted: 04/11/2024

Perfect First Time

It was our first time to Key West and we couldn’t have picked a better company to work with. The house, location, communication and provided services are top notch. They go above and beyond to make sure all your desires are met. They even mailed my Fitbit back to me after I left it at the house. Will use again and highly recommend to anyone traveling to Key West.

- Sarah R , Posted: 03/31/2024

Amazing

Greatly enjoyed our stay. The place is amazing. Would definitely come back.

- Mariola P , Posted: 03/03/2024

On the quiet end of Duval!

We had 6 adults staying and had a great time! Close to Duval St but on the quiet end so it didn't feel like it. Had a late flight so we were able to store our luggage with Last Key, which was very nice. Will definitely be returning to Key West!

- Kathy C , Posted: 02/11/2024

The property was exactly as nice as advertised

Perfect for our group of six adults. The location was convenient, and the house was clean.

- Sue O , Posted: 02/04/2024

Wonderful

We were at 516 Catherine St from 12/23 to 12/30.  The place was wonderful.   Christian, our guest services coordinator at Last Key Realty, was very attentive.   We would recommend this rental to everyone and will definitely be back.

- Debbie F , Posted: 01/07/2024

Fantastic

Fantastic house, perfect for 5 people in our group. Pool was nice and the hosts were fantastic about response and helpfulness!

- Nicholas C , Posted: 12/24/2023

Wonderful Thanksgiving

We spent a wonderful Thanksgiving weekend in Key West at the charming Casa Amarilla. The home is in a fantastic location and close to the action just off of Duval Street. The home was comfortable and convenient for our family of six. Last Key was professional, responsive and very helpful throughout our time in Key West. Highly recommend booking a home through them, including Casa Armailla. Every day should be a Key West day!

- Randy E , Posted: 12/24/2023

The location was perfect, as was the entire property!

The interior was charming and had everything you would need to enjoy your stay. The Last Key property manager responded very quickly when I had questions. I would definitely recommend this property if you're looking for a three-bedroom!

- Lori M , Posted: 12/17/2023

Perfection

Everything was perfect. We wanted relaxing... We got relaxing. We wanted an easy walk... We got an easy walk. They even had a Key Lime Pie for us. Really amazing!!!

- Greg T , Posted: 11/12/2023

5 Stars

Wonderful location, adorable house and perfect for our stay.

- Jennifer R , Posted: 10/18/2023

Awesome!

Nice clean place with everything you need in the perfect location. Everything was great!!

- Robert K , Posted: 09/17/2023

Felt like Home

Clean, well situated, well stocked and beautifully decorated, the Casa Amarilla really met all our standards. Traveling with 4 children can be exhausting, but when we got in the house, the professional service and good care of our host helped us make ourselves at « home ». We enjoyed our stay and would recommend warmly booking with the same team.

- Alexandre P , Posted: 09/17/2023

5 stars

Very nice place, clean, and check in process was seamless

- Jerod L , Posted: 08/27/2023

5/5

The home was wonderful. Exactly as advertised, and the customer service was amazing.

- Shannon J , Posted: 08/06/2023

Great Home

Was clean and up-to-date decor. Perfect for our weekend adult trip.

- Leslie S , Posted: 07/09/2023

Amazing Customer Service

Charlie, Patrick and Christian and the whole company were exceptionally helpful and kind. They exceeded my expectations!

- Lauren B , Posted: 06/18/2023

Can't ask for more!

Exactly as advertised. Super easy check in/check out. Everything we needed and more.

- Caitlin S , Posted: 05/14/2023

5/5

We enjoyed our stay. The house was clean, fully stocked. Great communication with the rental company!!!

- Julie C , Posted: 05/07/2023

Great 3 Night Stay

We are a family of six traveling for spring break. We spent 3 wonderful nights at Casa Amarilla. The location was perfect, and we were able to walk to almost everything. We especially loved the Cuban coffee house at the corner! We enjoyed the relaxing outdoor space out back in the afternoon, and also found the house very comfortable and well-stocked. I would definitely rent this home again.

- Sarah V , Posted: 04/09/2023

Fabulous!

A wonderful location, could walk anywhere. Kudos to our host whenever we called with questions, she had great recommendations!! Definitely would book again if coming to Key West!!❤️

- Anita H , Posted: 03/26/2023

Plenty of room and everything you could want!

Key West was a great destination for a family get-together / break from the winter weather. This property is in an excellent location, a quiet street but a short distance from Duval. There was plenty of room for 5 adults and a really nice back pool area. It has every amenity we could think of (beach towels, sunscreen, games, bug spray, coffee, tea, etc…). We look forward to going back!!!

- Amy P , Posted: 03/26/2023

Clean, cute & convenient!

Clean, cute & convenient location! Christian was very nice to work with! Definitely love to stay here again!!

- Kim H , Posted: 03/26/2023

Best Vacation Ever!

We just returned from our week in Casa Amarilla and it was the best experience ever!!  The house was immaculate when we arrived and it was everything that we were hoping for.  Alice's communications were great and made access simple.  Off-street parking was a great addition to this lovely property.  The kitchen was well equipped for cooking, the front porch was great for relaxing as well as the back patio and the dipping pool.  Just the right temperature and absolutely lovely to relax in!!  Everything about this property is welcoming and Last Key Realty is a pleasure to deal with.  We're already looking forward to returning next year!!

- Toni T , Posted: 02/26/2023

Amazing!

Amazing trip! Everything was as expected and we had a great time! More than accommodating!

- LaShawn B , Posted: 02/12/2023

Definitely a place to return to!

Stayed in many places in Key West, this is a definite return. You will be impressed with this place. Clean and very convenient to everything. Huge plus up....It has a driveway for parking:)))

- Todd R , Posted: 01/29/2023

A Perfect Rental!

This well-appointed property is just off Duval Street, yet street noise was never a problem! We walked to everything that we wanted to see in Key West, and loved having excellent Cuban coffee and breakfast just steps away. The property was very comfortable for 6 adults, with a charming back garden, a comfortable living room, and a larger than expected living room. Highly recommended!

- Anne B , Posted: 01/29/2023

Christmas in the Keys

Brought my adult children for a Christmas weekend. Very nice, well provisioned house. Awesome location. Clean and as advertised. The Last Key folks were great. Gave us some great restaurant recommendations.

- David R , Posted: 01/08/2023

Key West for Christmas!

Our family of 5 stayed here for 4 nights between Christmas and New Years. We enjoyed this location near the quieter end of Duval Street. The pool was not big, but our 3 kids (10, 8, and 5) really had fun swimming--the pool is heated which helped because our first 2 days were in the 60s. Highlights include walking to some great restaurants for dinner and a half-day sailing trip/eco-tour. The property was clean and kitchen had what we needed to make breakfast and lunch. One bedroom at the front of the house had some noise from the street, not unexpected and not enough to keep someone up all night. The back 2 bedrooms were perfectly quiet. We would stay here again.

- Nick D , Posted: 01/08/2023

Couldn’t have asked for a better home away from home!

There were 5 of us on a girls' trip, the house was plenty big & could have fit one more person. Clean, well furnished & charmingly appointed. There was space in the driveway for a Suburban AND a golf cart. Which on the island is essential, lol, both for parking & the golf cart, well, that’s just fun! Worth it to get the pool heated….it felt great! Also, this property comes with concierge service, and a perfectly wonderful house manager, Alice! Easy to communicate with, responds instantly, & friendly! No issues at all with the house. Another plus is the location!!! Within walking distance to Duval Street. I would most certainly rent this property again!!!

- Isabel D , Posted: 10/18/2022

Perfect Getaway

This property was exactly as described and such a great location! The kitchen was very large and had everything we needed to make dinners.

- Rhonda K , Posted: 09/14/2022

The Perfect 20th Anniversary Trip!

This property is amazing and exactly what we were looking for to celebrate our 20th anniversary! The house is fantastic and immediately feels like home, the pool area has the perfect amount of privacy, the kitchen has everything we needed and more! We utilized the kitchen and grill multiple times and never lacked for anything. Loved the location and proximity to restaurants and beaches. We rented a golf cart but easily could’ve walked anywhere we needed to go, except the grocery and airport but there are plenty of Ubers.

 

Last Key Realty was a dream to work with and we would definitely rent through them again. Perfect customer service, prompt communication, and loved the flowers and Prosecco upon arrival ❤️❤️. The concierge service pre-arrival is phenomenal!

- Brandi H , Posted: 09/04/2022

1st Timer - Loved it!

First time using VRBO. Process was easy, accurate, and we were so happy with the place. Last Key Resort property managers were amazing! Communication was spectacular and helpful each time we reached out. Would easily rent from LKR again. Will absolutely be back.

- Aaron S , Posted: 08/16/2022

Fantastic property!

We had a wonderful stay and the house met all of my family's needs! The pool was amazing and we quite enjoyed all the vacation amenities. Even though it is generally a quiet neighborhood, the trash trucks and any motorcycles can be easily heard. Overall, VERY lovely stay and we would stay again!

- Caitlin K , Posted: 08/14/2022

Everything you're looking for!

We really enjoyed our stay here. We were within walking distance to everything and the house had everything we needed!

- Meagan W , Posted: 06/12/2022

Fantastic House!
This house was immaculate! The location is unbeatable and the service from Last Key was exceptional. We will definitely be back!

- Anonymous U , Posted: 04/10/2022

A Perfect Trip

Casa Amarilla, just off Duval Street, in the quieter section of town was absolutely amazing!  The home was clean and beautiful with all modern conveniences.  The rocking chairs on the front porch and the heated saltwater pool and rear patio area were highlights of the property.  There was a driveway for one vehicle which came in handy for the days we rented a Jeep to explore the other Keys. The property was within walking distance of everything we needed – even the walk to/from Mallory Square was enjoyable because there was a lot to stop and see along the way.

 

We took advantage of the concierge service so the house would be stocked with groceries, a Key Lime pie, and adult beverages prior to our arrival.  This saved us time so we did not need to determine how/where to get these items - we could start enjoying ourselves immediately upon arrival at the house.

 

Greg was our personal guest coordinator.  He was attentive and checked in with us throughout our stay.  We had an issue with the air conditioner and upon notification, Greg immediately arranged for a same-day repair.

 

It wasn’t just a vacation – it was a celebration of special year birthdays and to meet friends we had not seen for several years.  Last Key Realty and the services offered made it an even more memorable experience than we ever could have imagined.  We plan to go back to Key West and will definitely book through Last Key Realty and will highly recommend them to everyone we know.

- Sheri P , Posted: 02/27/2022