Old Town Key West Rentals

Experience the charm and history of Key West with Last Key Realty's vacation rentals in historic Old Town. Our handpicked properties offer the perfect blend of luxury and comfort for your stay in one of the island's most iconic neighborhoods.

From cozy cottages to spacious homes with private pools, our Old Town Key West rentals accommodate couples, families, and groups. Each property is thoughtfully decorated and furnished, providing all the amenities you need to feel at home during your stay.

Stroll the streets of historic Old Town and discover the island's unique architecture, vibrant culture, and rich history. Our rentals are just steps away from world-class dining, shopping, entertainment, and some of Key West's most famous attractions, including the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, the Key West Lighthouse, and the Southernmost Point.

At Last Key Realty, we're committed to providing exceptional customer service to make your Old Town Key West rental experience unforgettable. Our team is available 24/7 to assist you with any needs or questions that may arise during your stay.

Book your Old Town Key West rental today and plan your dream vacation in paradise. Contact us for more information or browse our properties online. We can't wait to welcome you to historic Old Town Key West!


Properties Available 77 properties available
SOUTHERNMOST HOSPITALITY V is a luxurious private estate that occupies an entire corner of Old Town's famous Duval Street, just a block from the Southernmost Point. Don't let the address fool you... this upscale home has plenty of privacy in the spacious back yard with a tall fence surrounding the large private pool. Privacy also comes in the form
Southernmost Hospitality V
Private Home Pet Friendly
$800.00 - $4,772.00 / per night
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (73)
When the ‘Welcome to Key West’ sign hits your eye, like a big pizza pie, THAT’S AMORE! If you’ve ever visited Key West, you know how easy it is to fall in love with the charm of this little island. It’s even easier to fall in love when staying in a lavishly decorated and furnished, fully stocked, historic home in the heart of Old Town, and THAT’S A
Monthly Rental Monthly Rental
Monthly Rental
A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)
That's Amore!
Private Home
$333.00 - $1,125.00 / per night
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 6 guests
There’s no doubt you’ve heard of Duval Street; phenomenal restaurants, eclectic shops and legendary nightlife. This immaculate condo is just a half block away, giving you access to everything Duval Street has to offer while still allowing you to get a restful night’s sleep. SOUL OF DUVAL truly captures the essence of what makes Key West so special,
Soul of Duval
Condo
$240.00 - $1,214.00 / per night
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Bathrooms 1 baths
Guests 4 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (99)
The moment you arrive at CASA AMARILLA and see the dual rocking chairs beckoning you to the front porch, you’ll feel the weight of the world start to lift from your shoulders as your vacation truly begins. Upon entering this adorable cottage, you’ll see the quaint interior is the perfect place to unwind, offering cozy bedrooms, a fully stocked kitc
Hot HOT 31
Casa Amarilla
Private Home Pet Friendly
$425.00 - $2,897.00 / per night
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (123)
Located across the street from Blue Heaven, above the delicious La Creperie French Cafe, sits THE PIRATE’S PENTHOUSE. This hidden gem is ideally located in the heart of Bahama Village and within walking distance to everything Duval has to offer. THE PIRATE’S PENTHOUSE has touches of maritime decor sprinkled throughout this spacious condo, complet
The Pirate's Penthouse
Condo
$333.00 - $1,683.00 / per night
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (53)
If you’d like to spend your month in a neighborhood engulfed in as much history as the Matecumbe Keys, look no further! Located on William Street in Old Town atop the Seaport Inn, MATECUMBE SUITE offers simple island comfort matched with easy access to all the action and historical landmarks. When you add on Last Key Realty’s Five-Star Guest Servic
Matecumbe Suite
Condo
$138.00 - $440.00 / per night
Bedrooms 1 bedrooms
Bathrooms 1 baths
Guests 4 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (2)
For many, the artistic island culture of Key West is an intricate piece of its magic. THE ARTISTS' MUSE is an ode to that notion. This home, with its rich history of artists living in residence or visiting as guests, has been recently redesigned to celebrate art, culture, and the upscale island life. A spacious main living and dining area, a brand
Monthly Rental Monthly Rental
Monthly Rental
A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)
The Artists' Muse
Private Home
$300.00 - $990.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (13)
All year long you dream of a getaway to capture that feeling of Key West's ENDLESS SUMMER - carefree days spent tooling around Old Town on bicycles or wandering the island streets in flip flops with the sun warming your shoulders. No plans, nowhere to be, no deadlines - only a to-do list of making memories with your family and friends and possibly
Hot HOT 37
Endless Summer
Private Home Pet Friendly
$675.00 - $3,843.00 / per night
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (223)
Get ready to reel in Last Key Realty’s newest vacation home! THE WICKED TUNA is a classic Key West home located in one of the most desirable areas of Old Town. This tastefully restored home features a historic appearance and charm, while offering all the modern conveniences one could desire. Located just down the street from the historic seaport, y
Monthly Rental Monthly Rental
Monthly Rental
A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)
The Wicked Tuna
Private Home Pet Friendly
$225.00 - $682.00 / per night
Bedrooms 2 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 4 guests
THE GILDED PINEAPPLE is a classic Key West home located on one of the most desirable streets in Old Town. This completely renovated, historic home gets its’ name from the elegant, oversized golden door knocker shaped like a pineapple that graces the front door – one of the many subtle touches that adds to the charm. THE GILDED PINEAPPLE features a
Monthly Rental Monthly Rental
Monthly Rental
A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)
The Gilded Pineapple
Private Home Pet Friendly
$400.00 - $1,110.00 / per night
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 6 guests
For the ultimate stay in America's Paradise, what could be more perfect for your whole group than AMERICANA TROPICALE? This festive and patriotic home will promise a one-of-a-kind island experience. AMERICANA TROPICALE has 4 spacious bedrooms each complete with its own en-suite bathroom for privacy, a private saltwater pool, a fully equipped kitch
Americana Tropicale
Private Home Pet Friendly
$625.00 - $3,039.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 5 (316)
This compound is fit for a Queen and her court! These professionally designed homes have everything you need - the location, the amenities and the impeccable service fit for royalty. From the QUEEN’S modern interior and heat-optional saltwater pool to the DUKE’S spacious layout and robust hot tub, your Highness will be treated to a luxurious stay.
The Duke & The Queen
Compound Pet Friendly
$800.00 - $4,639.00 / per night
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 7 baths
Guests 18 guests

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree