Key West Rentals with Pool

Experience the pinnacle of an island paradise with our luxurious Key West rentals, each featuring a private pool. Enjoy your private retreat's ultimate blend of sun, fun, and turquoise water. Our offerings span a diverse range, from cozy two-bedroom homes to grand eight-bedroom estates, all meticulously designed to cater to your unique preferences.

Embrace the warm Key West sun as you dip into your private pool, the perfect respite after exploring the island's many charms. And when the weather cools, our heated pools ensure your swim remains as enjoyable as ever.

Our private pool rentals are excellent for those who value intimacy and privacy. These homes are ideally suited for families and groups, offering the ideal setting for a tranquil vacation. For guests staying a month or longer, pool heating is included in your package, while those on shorter stays can add this feature for a nominal fee during checkout.

But the luxury continues after the pool. Our rental properties have many amenities to ensure complete comfort during your stay. Benefit from our personalized concierge services and a unique on-site property introduction - no need for office check-ins here. Start your vacation the moment you step onto the property.

Spread across the enchanting island of Key West, each of our locations offers its unique charm. Experience a truly luxurious getaway in our private pool rentals and uncover the true essence of a Key West vacation.

140 properties available

Key West has a unique way of appealing to anyone and everyone that visits the island, and it's easy to see why: the laid-back way of life, the historic charm and walkability of Old Town, and the overall 'good vibes' that the island has to offer those needing an escape from the day to day hustle and bustle of the real world. These same appealing cha

Good Vibrations

Private Home

$599^.00 - $2,994^.00 / per night

It doesn't get any 'sweeter' than vacationing with a large group of your closest friends and family in America's Paradise. As a combination of two side-by-side private homes, SWEET AMERICANA not only offers plenty of comfortable accommodations for the whole crew but is an extremely rare find in the center of Old Town Key West. Located at the end of

Sweet Americana

Compound

$1,300^.00 - $6,138^.00 / per night

In the same way that the island of Key West has captured the hearts of so many, this charming monthly vacation home will capture yours. ISLAND INSPIRATION combines the appearance and charm of a historic Keys home, with all of the modern conveniences you have come to appreciate. This special home is situated on Margaret Street at the edge of where O

Monthly Rental

A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)

Island Inspiration

Private Home

$240^.00 - $913^.00 / per night

GREEN TURTLE COTTAGE will help you come out of your shell and slow down to a turtle’s pace. This 2 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home is located in the highly sought after Truman Annex neighborhood, putting it within walking distance to Old Town's most treasured restaurants and attractions. GREEN TURTLE COTTAGE is a relaxed home that features coastal, beac

2026 Changes

Starting January 1, 2026 every home in Truman Annex (including this one) will become a monthly-only rental. This is due to a new City Ordinance, so it will need to be rented for a minimum of 29 nights. Call 305-292-6266 for further information.

Green Turtle Cottage

Private Home

$415^.00 - $1,411^.00 / per night

This freshly renovated condo is located at 1800 Atlantic Blvd on the beach, just steps from the ocean and sand in your toes. You'll be able to enjoy quiet afternoons at CONCH IN THE TREETOPS with those balmy Key West breezes wafting through the floor-to-ceiling glass doors, while sitting on your private balcony surrounded by the palm tree tops. CON

Construction Notice

There will be concrete restoration of every balcony in this complex through Summer 2026. This construction WILL impact your stay. Call us at 305-292-6266 prior to making a reservation.

Conch in the Treetops

Condo

$200^.00 - $1,263^.00 / per night

The moment you arrive at CASA AMARILLA and see the dual rocking chairs beckoning you to the front porch, you’ll feel the weight of the world start to lift from your shoulders as your vacation truly begins. Upon entering this adorable cottage, you’ll see the quaint interior is the perfect place to unwind, offering cozy bedrooms, a fully stocked kitc

HOT 27

Casa Amarilla

Private Home

$425^.00 - $3,053^.00 / per night

DOCKSIDE DAYDREAMS is a tastefully decorated villa located in the Coconut Mallory Resort & Marina with two large community pools with plenty of chaises. There are also boat slips available on-site for rent if you want to bring your boat.THE LIVING AREA...This modern home has just undergone a complete renovation to a very high standard. No expen

Dockside Daydreams

Townhome

$200^.00 - $815^.00 / per night

You don’t often find new construction in Old Town, the historic district of Key West known for classic conch homes and walkable streets, but recently a spectacular new home was built smack dab in the middle of it all. CASITA OLIVIETTA is a newly built breathtaking home that allows you to enjoy the luxury of brand-new construction in the prime locat

HOT 29

Casita Olivietta

Private Home

$215^.00 - $775^.00 / per night

Traveling with a large group requires a special home. To maximize comfort, large common areas are offered both indoor and outdoor. Private bedroom accommodations with en-suite bathrooms and TVs are a must. And don't forget about the location! This home is easily accessible to the favorites of Old Town for when the group (finally) reaches a decision

HOT 30

Monthly Rental

La Grande Reunion

Private Home

$400^.00 - $1,315^.00 / per night

This precious 2 bedroom cottage with its coral front door will charm you from the moment you walk in the front gate. The front porch is private, for some quiet time reading a book. Inside, you'll see that PUERTA CORALINA reflects the simpler side of tropical living but with some useful updates.THE LIVING AREA...The living room of PUERTA CORALINA is

HOT 40

Puerta Coralina

Private Home

$370^.00 - $2,067^.00 / per night

Imagine a home with floor-to-ceiling panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean from every room. WINDSWEPT PALMS has been thoughtfully decorated and furnished. The modern, upscale furniture is complemented with splashes of color throughout the home. The balcony wraps 270 degrees around the condo, with seating for everyone in your group. WINDSWEPT PALMS

HOT 33

Windswept Palms

Condo

$445^.00 - $2,424^.00 / per night

Coordinating the entire gang for a dream Key West wedding, reunion, or simply a vacation of a lifetime is hard enough... let Last Key Realty make the accommodations easy for you. ALL TOGETHER NOW is an entire block of private homes just steps from Duval Street, all yours to enjoy and with everything needed for a large group getaway: a total of thir

All Together Now

Compound

$2,185^.00 - $9,514^.00 / per night

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

First Name

Last Name

Phone Number

Email Address

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Comments

I agree Sign me up! I agree to receive information about promotional offers and rental info via phone, email or SMS. You can unsubscribe at anytime. Privacy Policy